What is the best yeast for pizza according to Expert Bakers 2023?

Affiliate Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.. That means if you make a purchase through any of these links, Feed Smartly earns a small commission.

Sharing is caring!

Is yeast necessary for pizza dough? Yes, yeast is one of the vital ingredients a pizza dough needs to taste flavorful. Baking bread at home requires that you add active dry yeast into the flour to make the bread dough rise. Most people have been using active dry yeast, as well as instant dry yeast, to leaven or puff their home made pizza dough. If you have baked pizza for a year or more, you probably know which yeast is the best for your favorite pizza. But what about most beginners?, Which is the best yeast for pizza?

It can’t be denied that a high-quality yeast is important to making a great pizza dough. In this article, I will guide you on how to choose the best yeast for making your favorite pizza recipe. I will also tell which yeast brand is best for pizza according to professional and culinary experts.  I will not forget to answer the many questions that often come up when making pizza at home.

Let us get started!


The Role of yeast in pizza dough

I wonder how pizza would taste if made without yeast. Would pizza recipe without yeast taste good or bad? One thing is certain, a pizza dough not leavened with yeast isn’t going to taste the same was as yeast-made pizza, because it lacs those yeasty-taste byproducts. The unleavened pizza dough would be denser, terribly hard and somehow, would have a nasty taste.

How does yeast work in a pizza dough?

Yeast is a living microorganism, a form of fungi, which helps to ferment sugars. When you add yeast to a bread or pizza dough, it you break down the carbohydrates (sugars) in the flour into alcohol and release carbon dioxide CO2 gas in the dough.

Your pizza or bread dough rises or puffs up and gets a lighter texture, thanks to the CO2 bubbles, combined with the little acids, and the alcohol. These byproducts trapped inside your pizza dough give that delicious bready flavor, in addition to the light and fluffy pizza crust.

Like bread, a pizza dough that takes longer to rise taste more flavorful than pizza that hasn’t had time to puff and be proofed. When the dough is fully  risen, the CO2 forms air pockets in the pizza dough as it escapes. The pizza yeast later gets killed by the heat of the oven or pizza stone.

If you are going to make your own pizza crust at home, you are the one in control of the ingredients. So the type of flavor you want to get decides which yeast you have to use and in what measurement. You can switch between yeast. If you have active dry yeast for a pizza dough recipe that needed instant yeast, we will show you how to convert between dry and instant yeast.

Read more : Littke-known benefits of measuring baking ingredients by weight


Best yeasts for pizza dough

I used to think the type of yeast in a pizza does not matter, and there is no doubt that some beginner bakers think the same. It is a misconception that yeast for making pizza is more or less similar.

My baking experience shows that different yeast would give different flavor, rise and varying characteristics to the same amount of pizza dough.

For example, Fresh yeast is absolutely great for making Neapolitan. Would active dry yeast give the same flavor and texture?

The undeniable truth is that, with the right techniques and procedures, you can make a great pizza with any type of yeast.

1. best dry yeast for pizza

2. best instant yeast for pizza

3. best sourdough yeast for pizza



Which yeast is better for pizza?

What is the best type of yeast for pizza dough? Here is our guide on the best yeast for pizza

Yeast is the vital ingredient to making a delicious flavor pizza with a good texture. Your type of yeast matters for the kind of pizza crust and makes the difference between good pizza and the best pizza. Again, your yeast type determines how you mix the ingredients for your homemade pizza recipe.

We are going to talk about four yeast types. All the yeast types will actually make you’re a perfect and great pizza and the best yeast for your pizza also depends on the flavor you want to get at the end. Here are the best yeast for making pizza dough that tastes great.


1. Active Dry yeast – Best available yeast for pizza

Active dry yeast is very common and widely used for home baking. As the name suggests, the active dry yeast is living cells that have been dried or inactivated to give them a longer shell life. Think of dehydrating your leafy vegetable for a durable storage that is the same for active dry yeast. Whenever you are making pizza, you’ll need to proof(mix with warm water) or rehydrate to activate the yeast cells so that they can carry out the fermentation of the pizza dough.

Active dry yeast is the best available yeast for pizza making. You can buy it in a supermarket, online stores and local glossary stores. Because the active dry yeast is readily available, sold in 7grams packages(packs), I recommend it as a great everyday pizza yeast for your kitchen.

Active dry yeast comes in granular form, almost like little grains of rice. After your pizza recipes, you can store the left-over for your next baking process, even 30 days later.


2. Sourdough yeast – Best flavor yeast for pizza dough

Sourdough yeast - Best flavor yeast for pizza dough

Sourdough yeast is the cheapest yeast for pizza and the best leavening agent that gives pizza a flavorful taste. It is formed from combining both bacteria and yeast. The bacteria help to produce lactic acid, which contributes to the sourness you normally get from yoghurt.

Sourdough yeast, like instant yeast, needs no proofing or mixing with warm water. You only have to create the culture by mixing flour, warm water and the sourdough yeast. The advantage is that you can store and use the culture for many later pizza making.

The efficiently is super high and rises a pizza dough within 10-12 hours where active dry instant could take 16-24 hours. Your pizza dough made from sourdough yeast gets a little sour, mouth-watering, sweet, and incredibly yeasty taste, when it comes out from the home pizza oven.



3. Instant yeast – Best easy-to-use yeast for making pizza

Instant yeast, as the same describes, is actually a more reactive active dry yeast. The cell is more active that you need no mixing with warm water or rehydration to making it raise your pizza dough.

Most experienced bakers, say, with instant yeast, you just have to sprinkle the instant yeast granules directly into the pizza dough mixture. No proofing is required, so no time is wasted.

Instant yeast will immediately start fermentation, the moment you add into the flour or ingredients for your pizza dough. That means instant yeast makes pizza dough rise faster than active yeast. The presence of salt and sugar have little to no effect on its fermentation activity.

Instant yeast is the best yeast for pizza making if you are in a hurry to get the product out of the pizza oven for breakfast.



4. Fresh yeast–best yeast for pizza dough quick rise

is fresh yeast good for pizza? - Fresh yeast–best yeast for pizza dough quick rise

Fresh yeast looks like a solid block and that is why it is commonly called cake yeast or compressed yeast. This cake yeast has a high moisture content and is highly perishable, unlike other commercial yeasts. You will hardly find in fresh yeast local stores, except in refrigerators at the supermarkets.

Fresh yeast is best used only for making pizza for special occasions by culinary experts and experience bakers. No need for blooming like for active dry yeast. All you need is to crumble the fresh yeast into the baking flour before adding other ingredients.

Professional bakers suggest you use dissolve your fresh yeast in water first, before adding salt and sugar. This is to ensure the yeast gets evenly distributed in the pizza flour. Since fresh yeast is not concentrated or processed as active dry yeast, it is great for making fast rise pizza dough.

The downside is that its shell life is short. You must store it in an air-tight container at in a refrigerator or freezer.

Is pizza better with fresh yeast?

Fresh yeast perishes quickly than any other yeast, and not very common in stores. Fresh yeast makes pizza dough rise faster, and the fresh yeast baked pizza comes with a little more subtle flavour when compared to dry yeast.



Is there a Pizza Yeast?

Do you need special yeast for pizza dough? May be. Most people have been making their favorite pizza from whatever yeast they got. It was not until recently that a special yeast brand – Fleischmann’s came out with what they called “Pizza Crust Yeast.”

This pizza yeast has characteristics similar to instant yeast, but with a little difference. The little difference is that the pizza yeast contains dough conditioner–a dough relaxer called L-Cysteine. This L-Cysteine substance is simply another kind of amino acid that causes the gluten bonds in the pizza dough to relax. This gives the dough easy to stretch and shape.

Is pizza yeast the same as dry yeast?

No, pizza yeast is similar to instant yeast, but has additives for dough shaping. The good thing is that you can substitute Pizza Yeast for another type of yeast in any pizza recipe.

What kind of yeast is pizza yeast?

Instant Yeast – Bread Machine Yeast or Pizza Yeast is essentially Instant Yeast, just with some slight additives to best suit the use (bread machine or pizza making). When best used for its intended purpose, pizza yeast will perform similarly to Instant Yeast.

Do you need special yeast for pizza dough?

There is no special yeast except the pizza yeast. So, can you use normal yeast for pizza dough? Yes. You can use instant, active dry or fresh yeast for homemade pizza recipe.


What about Caputo Lievito yeast for pizza?

best yeast for pizza dough - Antimo Caputo Lievito Active Dry Yeast 3.5 Ounce Can - Made in Italy - Perfect with 00 Flour
Antimo Caputo Lievito Active Dry Yeast 3.5 Ounce Can – Made in Italy – Perfect with 00 Flour


First, what is Caputo yeast anyway? Caputo Lievito is a pizza yeast – a traditional Italian dry active yeast made from Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The Caputo yeast is multiplied by feeding them Italian molasses. When the molasses are taken out, the yeast cells are dried, and stored in packs. The Caputo yeast gives a characteristic flavor to the dough and has been used for pizza baking for decades.

Is Caputo yeast active or instant?

Caputo yeast is active dry yeast–a great traditional Neapolitan pizza yeast that goes with any king of pizza dough. If you try it with the Neapolitan Type 00 flour, you’ll get a nice rise and light pizza crust. The Caputo is sold in bigger containers than the usual 7g packs of active dry yeast. It almost measures 100g and sells at a relatively cheaper price.

Is Caputo Lievito yeast best for pizza dough?

With a Caputo Lievito yeast, your pizza dough rise is consistent and can last for about 20-24 hours at low to room temperature. Mixing the Italian yeast with flour and other ingredients produces an almost elastic pizza dough ball, relatively easy to stretch when kneading. The flavor of the pizza crust tastes less yeasty from what you normally get from using a regular bread yeast. Moreover, the pizza crusts will taste crispy, and a bit soft inside.

while thinking of the best yeast for pizza, don't forget about the best pizza oven for home baking
best pizza oven for homeROCCBOX Gozney Portable Outdoor Pizza Oven – Includes Professional Grade Pizza Peel, Built-In Thermometer and Safe Touch Silicone Jacket – Propane Gas Fired, With Rolling Wood Flame


Instant vs Active Dry yeast–which is best yeast for pizza?

instant vs active yeast - which is the best type of yeast for pizza


Let us compare two yeasts for pizza -the Active dry yeast vs Instant Yeast, which is the best yeast for pizza? Whether you want to make the tastiest pizza with chicken or just a cheesy pizza, instant and dry yeasts will often compete for your attention.

They are both available in your grocery store, and they also have alternatives. But which of them is best suited for baking delicious pizza? They both can also make a healthy pizza, but is one better than the other?

Active Dry yeast

To some bakers, active yeast is the best yeast for pizza overall, but it depends on factors.

  • Active yeast has a longer shelf life and can last up to 5 years in a freezer.
  • Active dry yeast is very popular and available in most supermarkets
  • Active dry yeast is inexpensive for any pizza art.
  • Slow rise gives the best flavor to your breakfast pizza

Unfortunately, Active dry yeast must be dissolved in warm water (100 degree Fahrenheit) for it to become active. It gives a slow rise too–it makes your Yummy Pizza dough to rise slowly.

Instant Dry yeast

  • Also called a quick rise or a fast rise yeast, people consider instant yeast as the best yeast for quick baking pizza projects.
  • If you don’t want to spend hours cooking pizza meals in the kitchen, instant yeast is a time-saver.
  •  The cells are not dormant and need no warm water to become active

Can you make pizza dough with both yeasts (active dry and instant yeast)?

No, only one specific yeast has to go into flour for your healthy pizza recipe. You can certainly use either active dry yeast or instant yeast to make pizza dough, not the two. You can always substitute one pizza yeast for the other.



Yeast to yeast conversion for pizza

What if your pizza recipe calls for active dry yeast, but you only have instant yeast? What if my pizza dough recipe requires instant yeast, and I only have active dry yeast at home?

If your pizza recipe is planned for one yeast and you want to substitute for another yeast, you have to swap the yeasts and calculate their equivalent amounts. How do you convert between yeasts when making pizza?

Convert active yeast to instant yeast

If you’re going to use instant yeast for the pizza instead of active dry yeast, experts recommend reducing the instant yeast amount of yeast by 25 percent. To convert Active to Instant: simply divide the equivalent quantity by 1.35.

Convert Instant yeast to active dry yeast

If you are making pizza at home which calls active dry yeast in place of instant yeast, you should increase the amount of the active dry yeast by about 25 percent. To swap Instant yeast to Active yeast, simply multiply the quantity by 1.35.

 Convert dry yeast to fresh yeast

If I only have fresh yeast, and my pizza dough recipes was planned for active dry yeast. What now? In that you are using fresh yeast in a pizza recipe that required dry yeast, double the amount of fresh yeast and crumble it into the liquid. To exchange Active yeast to Fresh yeast, multiply amount by 2.

Fresh yeast to active dry yeast

To convert Fresh yeast to Active dry yeast when making pizza, divide the yeast amount by 2.

Yeast conversion

Wrap Up with FAQS


Can I make pizza dough without yeast?

YES. If you don’t have a biological leavening agent like yeast for your pizza, baking powder is a chemical leaving agent) can work. Like the steam leavening agent, the baking powder makes your bread or pizza get an authentic puff but lacks the yeasty flavor.


Which brand of yeast is best?

Looking for the top best yeast perfect for baking delicious pizza, vegetarian pizza, pizza with chicken, Summer Pizza, Greek Pizza, Vegan Pizza and more? Here are a few brands of yeast for pizza, but they fall into active dry yeast, and instant yeast.

  • Meriah Instant Yeast.
  • DCL Active Dried Yeast.
  • Bruggeman Victoria Dry Yeast.
  • Edmond’s Dry Yeast.
  • Fleischmann’s RapidRise Instant Yeast.
  • Redstar All Natural Active Dry Yeast.
  • Saf-Instant Natural Instant Yeast Cake Bread Flour.
  • Mauri-Pan Instant Dry Yeast.

Read more: how to convert ingredients measurements  to Grams without any brainworks 


What is the best flour for pizza?

The type 00 or double zero flour is one of the best flour for pizza dough.


What is the difference of active yeast and instant yeast?

Active dry yeast is deactivated yeast, and needs proofing–addition to warm water to make it become active. It is warm water that rehydrate and removes it from the dormant state. On the other hand, instant yeast is efficiently working yeast cells, very active and ferments the pizza dough in a shorter time. IT needs no activation. You just add it directly to the liquid ingredients.


How much fresh yeast do you need for pizza?

For Home made pizza using fresh yeast dough using 500 grams (1.1 lb) Italian “00” or “0” type flour, 15 grams Fresh yeast (fresh compressed yeast) is the right amount. That is about 3% of of the quantity of the 00 flour, which can produce 5 large 30 cm diameter pizza. Other additions may include the fine salts, malt extract, virgin olive oil, and water.


Can I use bread yeast for pizza recipe?

Does bread yeast work for pizza? Yes, the regular yeast used for bread can be used for pizza. Instant, active or fresh yeast can rise bread and pizza doughs.


Is Fleischmann’s pizza yeast active dry yeast?

Not really. There’s a difference between Fleischmann’s pizza yeast and regular yeast. The Fleischmann’s Pizza Crust Yeast is good for mixing and kneading dough on the go, unlike active dry yeast. Besides, Fleischmann’s Pizza Crust Yeast is specially formulated pizza yeast which contains chemicals or enzymes added to relax the dough for easy shaping and stretching.


How do you activate dry yeast for pizza dough?

For the best performance, active dry yeast is inactive and needs activation.

  • Warm enough water( a glass) to 100°F
  • Pour in your sachet(7 grams) of active dry yeast
  • Stir thoroughly
  • Wait for 7-12 minutes for activation to occur
  • Add dry ingredients to it
  • Pour it all into the regular bread or pizza dough. Just pour it into the flour.

Some people add a teaspoon of sugar and a bit of flour.


Can l substitute instant yeast for pizza yeast?

Yes, if you have pizza yeast while your pizza recipes called for instant yeast, you can substitute your instant yeast for pizza yeast. For 1bour 1 teaspoon of instant yeast, add 1 teaspoon of pizza yeast by equivalent yeast conversion.


What happens if I put too much yeast in pizza dough?

Adding too much yeast into the pizza dough can cause the dough to rise too fast and overflow the bowl. Just doubling the yeast without increasing the pizza dough will cause the CO2 gas to be released before the flour is ready to expand. Too much yeast in a pizza dough may generate too much fermentation, with alcohol as byproducts. This will make the dough to start having a yeasty or beer smell.

How do you fix too much yeast in dough? The best thing is to reduce the yeast activity in the dough. If you added too much yeast to the bread or pizza dough, cold the dough (reduce the temperature of the dough) while it keeps rising at a decreasing rate.

So can you use too much yeast in pizza dough? No, never try it because it will cause fast rise and produce much less developed flavor. There is another question that comes up when baking at home. Should you double yeast when doubling the pizza dough?


How much instant yeast do I need for pizza?

While 1/4 teaspoon of active dry yeast is great for 500 grams of pizza dough, use less of the instant dry yeast, per the same 500 grams of dough.

How much instant yeast should I use a cup of flour? 1/2 teaspoon Instant (Bread Machine) yeast per cup of flour.

How much instant yeast is 500g flour? The baking rule is that you use about 1% dried yeast to flour. This means if your pizza dough needs 500g flour, add 5g instant yeast.

How much yeast do I need for 4 cups of flour? 2 and 1/4 teaspoons or one packet of dry yeast (2 and 1/4 teaspoons) or less instant yeast is ok for the 4 cups of flour.

Feel free to explore other breakfast time, other restaurants, recipes and other special foods in our official site feedsmartly.com

Sharing is caring!

Leave a Comment